The moon falls to earth ...

Please log in to view tutor details
By: Please log in to see tutor details
Subject: University Maths
Last updated: 27/11/2011
Tags: earth, kepler, moon, orbit
University Maths

A question from a Cambridge First Year Applied maths paper from the 60s.

A malignant deity stops the moon dead in its tracks and the moon falls under the Earth's gravity. How long will the moon take to hit the earth? (You may assume that the orbit of the moon is circular with radius R=240,000 miles, and you may take the earth as a point.)

Ans. One can do a tedious integral.

Alternatively, one can use the theory of orbits. The moon takes 1 month to orbit the earth; 2 bodies orbiting the earth with equal major axes have the same orbital period (Kepler's 3rd Law: see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kepler's_laws_of_planetary_motion). The 'new' orbit of the moon is just a diameter of the original circular orbit (if we ignore collision with the earth), which can be considered a very flat ellipse with the same major axis 2R. It follows that the orbital period is unchanged so it will take ¼ of a month to hit the earth (around 7 days).

(The question and answer are from memory; the answer was provided by Prof R  Lyttleton: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raymond_Lyttleton.)

 


Don Nicolson A-level Maths Tutor (Sheffield)

About The Author

I enjoy helping students to achieve their potential and to understand mathematics. As exam results are important, I will pass on tips for maximising marks.



Rate and Comment this article

Please Login or Register to rate/comment on this article


Tutors Wanted

  • Chemistry - Cambridge Pre-U Anywhere / Online Year 12, Av. 11/06 - 24/07, 5hrs per week
  • Native French tutor London for 16 yr old, live-in strong org. skills
  • Maths tutor Elstree, Hertfordshire 10 year old with dyscalculia, CRB
  • part time tutor to make bread east london food & hig cert
  • GCSE Maths Tutor Manchester CRB check
  • maths, science gcse tutor Colchester year9/10 student
  • Chemistry Tutor central London (EC1) AQA C3 only
View tutor jobs
Tutors: Download your free e-book!